Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Hopefully defensive democracy finally shows its teeth and they come through with the long-overdue ban of this fascist party.
 help



Democracy is when the government does what I want!

No but a democracy should protect democracy.

AfD is concluding with russia, a country which poisned people on EU ground.

AfD also has plenty of real nazis doing nazi shit and AfD is not excluding them.

AfD is not democracy. AfD is antidemocracy even if it would get elected democratically.


> AfD is not democracy. AfD is antidemocracy even if it would get elected democratically.

Here's a fun thing language-game to try: expand your definition of "democracy" to encompass your partisan political positions, don't tell anyone, yell from the rooftops that your opponents are "anti-democratic" and banning them is "democratic."

Then observe how you only convince yourself of your own righteousness, and further alienate the people you wished to persuade.


AfD is a facist party and anti-democratic.

AfD fights against mechanism we have in place to protect the democracy.

Has nothing to do with my own righteousness. AfD could easily do things against all of this garbage and they don't.


This is certainly what could be the case, except it isn't. It was decided in 1949 what the current understanding of democracy in Germany is. You could of course decide to define democracy as broad so that it also encompasses the Athenian democracy, but that is not what we currently mean when we speak of a liberal democracy.

If party A, being labeled as communist by party B, and party B, being labeled as fascistic by party A, both agree, as well as all other parties in-between, that you are a threat to democracy, maybe you are.

If you are looking for a party that labels itself democratic and all others anti-democratic, you need to look at the AfD themself.


Democracy isn't a dictatorship of the majority!

Sometimes, cultures democratically decide "hey we shouldn't be responsible for another World War and Holocaust" is worth legislating.

Sometimes, democracy needs defending from people using its privileges to get rid of it.


> Democracy is when the government does what I want!

One can (should?) tolerate a lot in an open, democratic society, but not (necessarily) everything:

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance

Then there's H.L. Mencken old line:

* “Democracy is the theory that the common people know what they want, and deserve to get it good and hard.”


I think the paradox of tolerance has been interpreted by many on the left in a way that flatters them and is convenient to their political ends. Forces that actually threaten democracy and tolerance are frequently ignored or swept under the rug, while the left's political opponents are demonized as not being tolerant enough to participate in democracy so they can be summarily dismissed.

IMHO this tactic is one of the drivers in the falling trust in institutions that we see across the western world. You can't simply dismiss your opposition as not tolerant enough as a way of winning a political argument.


I agree, a predicate of non-tolerance or non-democraticness should be in the conclusion of an argument, not in it's assertion or justification.

I'd recommend reading up on German constitutional theory and consider the historical precedent that might've lead them to realize the importance of having their democracy be defensive - something they're failing to live up to right now.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defensive_democracy


I'd say the majority doesn't want AfD, otherwise they would have voted for them. So let's not claim what is not due.

Good point. We should abolish any party that can't win an election.

Their electoral performance is irrelevant to their legality under Art 9 GG.

Tyranny is a cancer and Managed Democracy is the cure!

Other countries may not have learned the lessons of history Germany tried to rectify with Art 9 Par 2 GG, as is evident by comments like these.

Unfortunately, the Germans themselves have forgotten. Never Forget rings hollow these days.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: