Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Oh, I really hate these articles. Intriguing headline and then a horribly long story with all these pseudo-artistic details like "immediately noticed a tense quality in the ambulance driver’s voice" wich is just too bothersome to actually read it.

Some TLDR, anyone?



>> "pseudo-artistic details like "immediately noticed a tense quality in the ambulance driver’s voice""

You mean storytelling?


I can sympathize with OP, sometime we just want the info without pictures of the Beatles.


Seriously, I'm considering writing an HN filtering proxy that ignores these kinds of magazine pieces. I just don't have time to read them properly, even if they are interesting enough that I inevitably get drawn into some of them. That's just another factor in HN becoming a time-sink instead of a productive source of useful news. I suspect if we had the ability to downvote submissions as well as upvote, less of them would hit the front page in the first place, but I can't be certain.

As for this article, the writing is OK, but I honestly wonder sometimes if these authors are being paid by the word. Take the first paragraph for instance. Replace it entirely with, "It was a dark and stormy night". Did that make the article better, worse, or no different?

Had the same information been conveyed in far fewer words, I wouldn't have had to skim over parts and would have got a lot more out of it. There's definitely a place for articles like this, but I don't think HN is that place.


Sorry for wasting your time, I purposedly submitted this on Sunday, a slow news day.

I can agree though that sometimes it's hard to estimate time which you would spend on a story. I use a word-counting service (textalyser) for that, and this particular story is quite long even by longform standards: 7,800 words / 47,000 characters (with spaces).


Just ignore anything from medium.com and you'll be right more often than not.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: